| The One Ring | | Foil | $445.34 |
| Orcish Bowmasters | | Foil | $177.37Prices: PriceCharting |
| Galadriel, Light of Valinor | | Foil | $175.85Prices: PriceCharting |
| The One Ring | | Foil | $160.29Prices: PriceCharting |
| The One Ring | | Base | $135.96Prices: PriceCharting |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord | | Foil | $123.41 |
| Galadriel's Dismissal | | Foil | $85.07Prices: PriceCharting |
| Orcish Bowmasters | | Foil | $66.84 |
| Cavern-Hoard Dragon | | Foil | $65.86Prices: PriceCharting |
| Mithril Coat | | Foil | $61.76Prices: PriceCharting |
| Delighted Halfling | | Foil | $59.25Prices: PriceCharting |
| Orcish Bowmasters | | Base | $55.70 |
| Last March of the Ents | | Foil | $55.20Prices: PriceCharting |
| Flowering of the White Tree | | Foil | $47.88Prices: PriceCharting |
| Palantír of Orthanc | | Foil | $47.21Prices: PriceCharting |
| Galadriel, Light of Valinor | | Foil | $45.46 |
| Witch-king of Angmar | | Foil | $41.71Prices: PriceCharting |
| Dáin of the Ancient Halls | | Base | $40.70Prices: PriceCharting |
| Relic of Sauron | | Foil | $40.20Prices: PriceCharting |
| Arwen, Weaver of Hope | | Foil | $40.17Prices: PriceCharting |
| The Black Gate | | Foil | $39.51Prices: PriceCharting |
| Galadriel's Dismissal | | Foil | $39.31 |
| Tom Bombadil | | Foil | $39.04 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff | | Foil | $36.37Prices: PriceCharting |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord | | Foil | $35.85Prices: PriceCharting |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin | | Foil | $35.10Prices: PriceCharting |
| Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress | | Foil | $34.85Prices: PriceCharting |
| Mithril Coat | | Foil | $33.21 |
| Thranduil the Strategist | | Base | $32.48Prices: PriceCharting |
| Galadriel's Dismissal | | Base | $32.46 |
| Call Forth the Tempest | | Foil | $31.89Prices: PriceCharting |
| Mount Doom | | Foil | $31.08Prices: PriceCharting |
| Sauron, the Dark Lord | | Base | $30.46 |
| Galadriel, Light of Valinor | | Base | $30.06 |
| Aragorn, the Uniter | | Foil | $29.71 |
| Flame of Anor | | Foil | $29.46Prices: PriceCharting |
| Cavern-Hoard Dragon | | Foil | $28.98 |
| Delighted Halfling | | Foil | $28.67 |
| Mithril Coat | | Base | $26.37 |
| Cavern-Hoard Dragon | | Base | $26.19 |
| Minas Tirith | | Foil | $25.54Prices: PriceCharting |
| Palantír of Orthanc | | Foil | $25.52Prices: PriceCharting |
| Delighted Halfling | | Base | $25.23 |
| Last March of the Ents | | Foil | $25.19Prices: PriceCharting |
| Thorin, Company's Leader | | Base | $24.72Prices: PriceCharting |
| Raise the Palisade | | Foil | $24.59Prices: PriceCharting |
| Last March of the Ents | | Base | $23.65 |
| Rivendell | | Foil | $21.67Prices: PriceCharting |
| Gandalf, Shadow's Foe | | Base | $21.65Prices: PriceCharting |
| Sauron, the Lidless Eye | | Foil | $21.36Prices: PriceCharting |
| Palantír of Orthanc | | Base | $21.30 |
| Andúril, Narsil Reforged | | Foil | $21.19Prices: PriceCharting |
| Elven Chorus | | Foil | $20.42 |
| Chief of the Wilds | | Base | $20.32 |
| Call Forth the Tempest | | Foil | $19.98 |
| The Gaffer | | Foil | $18.97Prices: PriceCharting |
| Call Forth the Tempest | | Base | $18.65Prices: PriceCharting |
| Saruman of Many Colors | | Foil | $18.55Prices: PriceCharting |
| Flowering of the White Tree | | Foil | $17.87 |
| Relic of Sauron | | Foil | $17.67 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen | | Foil | $17.19Prices: PriceCharting |
| The Shire | | Foil | $17.10Prices: PriceCharting |
| Great Goblin, Foul-Hearted | | Base | $17.08Prices: PriceCharting |
| Reprieve | | Foil | $16.85Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bilbo's Ring | | Foil | $16.53Prices: PriceCharting |
| Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress | | Foil | $16.20 |
| Smaug the Impenetrable | | Foil | $16.17Prices: PriceCharting |
| Glamdring | | Foil | $15.96Prices: PriceCharting |
| Smaug the Impenetrable | | Base | $15.88 |
| Necklace of Girion | | Foil | $15.68 |
| Aragorn and Arwen, Wed | | Foil | $15.51Prices: PriceCharting |
| Arwen, Weaver of Hope | | Foil | $15.07 |
| Flowering of the White Tree | | Base | $14.91 |
| Witch-king of Angmar | | Foil | $14.84 |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin | | Foil | $14.45 |
| Dawn of a New Age | | Foil | $14.28Prices: PriceCharting |
| Minas Morgul, Dark Fortress | | Base | $14.21 |
| Andúril, Narsil Reforged | | Foil | $14.03 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff | | Foil | $13.98 |
| Raise the Palisade | | Foil | $13.91 |
| Necklace of Girion | | Base | $13.68 |
| The Black Gate | | Foil | $13.67 |
| Witch-king of Angmar | | Base | $13.44 |
| Relic of Sauron | | Base | $13.07 |
| Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff | | Base | $12.82 |
| Gríma, Saruman's Footman | | Foil | $12.72Prices: PriceCharting |
| The Black Gate | | Base | $12.49 |
| Mount Doom | | Foil | $12.17 |
| Arwen, Weaver of Hope | | Base | $12.05 |
| Raise the Palisade | | Base | $11.62 |
| Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin | | Base | $11.51Prices: PriceCharting |
| Andúril, Narsil Reforged | | Base | $11.49Prices: PriceCharting |
| Tom Bombadil | | Foil | $10.89 |
| Bolg, Erebor's Reckoning | | Base | $10.83Prices: PriceCharting |
| Minas Tirith | | Foil | $10.65Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bilbo's Ring | | Foil | $9.44 |
| Bard, Heir of Girion | | Base | $9.40Prices: PriceCharting |
| Tom Bombadil | | Base | $9.34Prices: PriceCharting |
| Andúril, Flame of the West | | Foil | $9.16Prices: PriceCharting |
| Elven Chorus | | Foil | $9.15Prices: PriceCharting |
| Shadow of the Enemy | | Base | $9.09Prices: PriceCharting |
| Minas Tirith | | Base | $9.04Prices: PriceCharting |
| Inferno Titan | | Base | $8.98Prices: PriceCharting |
| Mount Doom | | Base | $8.66 |
| The Gaffer | | Foil | $8.63 |
| Bilbo, Unexpected Adventurer | | Base | $8.53 |
| Dawn of a New Age | | Base | $8.26Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bilbo's Ring | | Base | $8.24 |
| Languish | | Base | $7.96Prices: PriceCharting |
| Elven Chorus | | Base | $7.74 |
| The Gaffer | | Base | $7.63Prices: PriceCharting |
| Flame of Anor | | Foil | $7.62 |
| Elvish Archdruid | | Base | $7.47Prices: PriceCharting |
| Dragon-Cursed Halls | | Foil | $7.15Prices: PriceCharting |
| Aragorn, the Uniter | | Foil | $7.10 |
| Orcish Siegemaster | | Base | $7.05Prices: PriceCharting |
| Aragorn, the Uniter | | Base | $6.93Prices: PriceCharting |
| Sauron, the Lidless Eye | | Foil | $6.92 |
| Troll of Khazad-dûm | | Base | $6.68Prices: PriceCharting |
| Night's Whisper | | Base | $6.66Prices: PriceCharting |
| Dragon-Cursed Halls | | Base | $6.62Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bag End Banquet | | Foil | $6.61Prices: PriceCharting |
| Reprieve | | Foil | $6.49 |
| Aragorn and Arwen, Wed | | Foil | $6.48 |
| Flame of Anor | | Base | $6.35 |
| Bag End Banquet | | Base | $6.01Prices: PriceCharting |
| Wayfarer's Bauble | | Base | $5.98 |
| Mirkwood Elk | | Base | $5.95 |
| Lórien Revealed | | Base | $5.90Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bilbo, Fellow Conspirator | | Base | $5.83 |
| Reprieve | | Base | $5.83Prices: PriceCharting |
| The Shire | | Foil | $5.75 |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen | | Foil | $5.49 |
| Sauron, the Lidless Eye | | Base | $5.47 |
| Thorin, King of Durin's Folk | | Foil | $5.45Prices: PriceCharting |
| Elvish Mystic | | Base | $5.32Prices: PriceCharting |
| Arwen, Mortal Queen | | Base | $5.17Prices: PriceCharting |
| Aragorn and Arwen, Wed | | Base | $5.03 |
| Andúril, Flame of the West | | Foil | $4.96Prices: PriceCharting |
| Thorin, King of Durin's Folk | | Base | $4.96Prices: PriceCharting |
| Rivendell | | Foil | $4.71 |
| Mentor of the Meek | | Base | $4.70Prices: PriceCharting |
| Rivendell | | Base | $4.61Prices: PriceCharting |
| Ori, Plate Stacker | | Base | $4.54 |
| The Shire | | Base | $4.53 |
| Dawn of a New Age | | Foil | $4.51 |
| Andúril, Flame of the West | | Base | $4.48Prices: PriceCharting |
| Stern Scolding | | Base | $4.29Prices: PriceCharting |
| Fíli and Kíli, Joyous | | Foil | $4.24 |
| Captain of Umbar | | Base | $4.15Prices: PriceCharting |
| Fíli and Kíli, Joyous | | Base | $3.99Prices: PriceCharting |
| Ori, Plate Stacker | | Foil | $3.88Prices: PriceCharting |
| Saruman of Many Colors | | Foil | $3.79 |
| Hithlain Knots | | Base | $3.74Prices: PriceCharting |
| Glamdring | | Foil | $3.69Prices: PriceCharting |
| Dawn of a New Age | | Base | $3.56 |
| Glamdring | | Base | $3.54 |
| Grey Havens Navigator | | Base | $3.03Prices: PriceCharting |
| Gríma, Saruman's Footman | | Base | $2.92 |
| Willow-Wind | | Base | $2.78Prices: PriceCharting |
| Saruman of Many Colors | | Base | $2.77 |
| Gríma, Saruman's Footman | | Foil | $2.72 |
| Colossal Whale | | Base | $2.62Prices: PriceCharting |
| Dragon's Desire | | Foil | $2.20Prices: PriceCharting |
| Nimrodel Watcher | | Base | $2.12Prices: PriceCharting |
| Knights of Dol Amroth | | Base | $2.08Prices: PriceCharting |
| Dragon's Desire | | Base | $2.02Prices: PriceCharting |
| Ithilien Kingfisher | | Base | $1.99Prices: PriceCharting |
| Long-Lost Lances | | Foil | $1.90Prices: PriceCharting |
| Long-Lost Lances | | Base | $1.84Prices: PriceCharting |
| Gandalf, Party Guest | | Foil | $1.81Prices: PriceCharting |
| Gandalf, Party Guest | | Base | $1.53Prices: PriceCharting |
| Minas Tirith Garrison | | Base | $1.49Prices: PriceCharting |
| Improvised Club | | Base | $1.14Prices: PriceCharting |
| Lothlórien Lookout | | Base | $1.08Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bitter Downfall | | Base | $1.02Prices: PriceCharting |
| Haunt of the Dead Marshes | | Base | $1.01Prices: PriceCharting |
| Goblin Fireleaper | | Base | $0.95Prices: PriceCharting |
| Rogue's Passage | | Base | $0.77 |
| Galadhrim Guide | | Base | $0.69Prices: PriceCharting |
| Banishing Light | | Base | $0.68Prices: PriceCharting |
| Merciless Executioner | | Base | $0.56Prices: PriceCharting |
| Celeborn the Wise | | Base | $0.55Prices: PriceCharting |
| Landroval, Horizon Witness | | Base | $0.54Prices: PriceCharting |
| Fiend Hunter | | Base | $0.52Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bilbo's Burglaring | | Base | $0.50Prices: PriceCharting |
| Guttersnipe | | Base | $0.50Prices: PriceCharting |
| Soldier of the Grey Host | | Base | $0.49Prices: PriceCharting |
| Bilbo's Burglaring | | Foil | $0.46Prices: PriceCharting |
| Errand-Rider of Gondor | | Base | $0.44Prices: PriceCharting |
| Pelargir Survivor | | Base | $0.44Prices: PriceCharting |
| Westfold Rider | | Base | $0.43Prices: PriceCharting |
| Battle-Scarred Goblin | | Base | $0.39Prices: PriceCharting |
| Olog-hai Crusher | | Base | $0.39Prices: PriceCharting |
| Smite the Deathless | | Base | $0.36Prices: PriceCharting |
| Eagles of the North | | Base | $0.32 |
| Dúnedain Blade | | Base | $0.31 |
| Esquire of the King | | Base | $0.30Prices: PriceCharting |
| Fog on the Barrow-Downs | | Base | $0.29Prices: PriceCharting |
| Gift of Strands | | Base | $0.29 |
| Fire of Orthanc | | Base | $0.27Prices: PriceCharting |
| Goblin Cratermaker | | Base | $0.27Prices: PriceCharting |
| Oliphaunt | | Base | $0.27Prices: PriceCharting |
| Elvish Visionary | | Base | $0.26 |
